1871 James B. Yager*
1872, 1873, 1874 Milton Boone*
1875 A. M. Woodson*
1876 Henry C. Brooking*
1877 Thomas H. West*
1878, 1879, 1880 Milton Boone*
1881 Dr. Minor T. Smith*
1882 A. M. Woodson*
1883 J. J. Robinson*
1884 Jacob Crouse*
1885 A. M. Woodson*
1886, 1887 Milton Boone*
1888, 1889, 1890, 1891 T. W. Greene, Sr*
1892 W. H. H. Brown*
1893 T. W. Greene, Sr*
1894 Jacob Crouse*
1895 T. W. Greene, Sr*
1896 A. J. Collings*
1897, 1898 T. W. Greene, Sr*
1899 Robert Hussey*
1900, 1901 N. J. Day*
1902 A. A. Hobbs*
1903 Grant Day*
1904 Arthur Young*
1905 William F. Hall*
1906 Sam Robinson*
1907 A. A. Hobbs*
1908 Isaac N. Greene*
1909, 1910 Marcus S. Pendleton*
1911 William F. Hall*
1912, 1913 O. J. Greene*
1914, 1915 W. F. Muir, Sr*
1916 Hiram Graham*
1917 H. B. Greene*
1918 Hiram Graham*
1919 Samuel Hussey*
1920 J. R. Schoflin*
1921 Jesse F. Cole, Sr*
1922 George Balch*
1923 Samuel Hussey*
1924 Errol Huffman*
1925 Walter Willsey*
1926 Edward Mantle*
1927 Robert Lewis*
1928 E. G. O’Flaherty*
1929 J. L. Robinson*
1930 J. H. Greene*
1931 J. E. Burch*
1932 J. R. Short*
1933 O. S. Widener*

1934 A. G. Robinson*
1935 Harold Wright*
1936 T. W. Greene, Jr*
1937 Morris Stout*
1938 Willis Pettigrew*
1939 Claude Strohm*
1940 James Herndon*
1941 Virgil Dryer*
1942 Charles (Sam) Nolen*
1943 Emmeret Enright*
1944 Clark Fegert*
1945 Sam Nichols*
1946 Howard Ward*
1947 Carl Schulte*
1948 Gus Johnson*
1949 J. M. Spencer*
1950 Clay Fleming*
1951 Henry W. Poetner*
1952 Merritt Goddard*
1953 Nelson P. Brouilette*
1954 Don L. Gregory*
1955 Harry Cole*
1956 Emmett Stephenson*
1957 Stanley Townsend*
1958 Robert Ryan*
1959 Roy Bly*
1960 Charles Bragg*
1961 Lloyd Kelly*
1962 Kenneth Bachman*
1963 William Robinson*
1964 Norman Walker*
1965 Orval Adams*
1966 Thomas M. Vaughn*
1967 Arthur Eugene Alexander*
1968 Chriss L. Green, Jr*
1969 Arthur W. Myers*
1970 John Rittermeyer*
1971 W. Russell Foust*
1972 James H. Hartman*
1973 Dwight L. Pickinpaugh*
1974 Earl L. Kenney, Jr*
1975 Robert S. Bailey*
1976 Robert K. Lynn*
1977 Everett J. Hays*
1978 Victor L. Ford*
1979 Marion W. Eilers*
1980 Jo M. Fisher*
1981 George E. Marsden*
1982 Franklin B. Harding*
1983 Worth C. Johnson, Jr*